elizabeth rhodes
Jun 25, 2026"Got a medium soft serve vanilla. ice cream was good. They gave discount for us in our EMS uniforms."
Ice Cream Shop 4.8· 273 reviews
Schoolhouse Creamery
New York, United States
Discover Schoolhouse Creamery in Windsor, NY offering a variety of Hershey's flavors, soft serve, sundaes, and milkshakes in a charming schoolhouse setting.
4.8 / 5
Guest rating
273
Reviews
Ice Cream Shop
Cuisine
New York
City
Overview
About Schoolhouse Creamery
Schoolhouse Creamery is a quaint ice cream shop located at 17 Fox Farm Rd in Windsor, NY. Housed in a restored one-room schoolhouse, this spot offers both hard Hershey's ice cream and soft serve options including vanilla, chocolate, and twists.
Visitors can expect a casual, no-table-service environment with shaded picnic bench seating outdoors. The creamery is known for a broad selection of flavors and toppings, as well as milkshakes and sundaes. Typical visits last about 15 minutes, providing a quick sweet break.
Accessibility is considered with a wheelchair accessible entrance, and dogs are welcome outside. Paid parking is available nearby, and onsite Wi-Fi can be used during the visit. Credit and debit cards are accepted as payment methods.
Ice Cream Shop Historic Schoolhouse Wheelchair Accessible Wi-Fi Available Accepts Credit/Debit Cards Paid Parking Lot Dogs Allowed Outside Typical Visit: 15 min
Quick facts
- Phone: +1 607-499-2015
- Location: 17 Fox Farm Rd, Windsor, NY 13865
- Payment: Credit & Debit Cards
- Dining: No table service, onsite only
- Accessibility: Wheelchair entrance
- Parking: Paid lot available
- Popular Flavors: Chocolate, Vanilla & Chocolate Twist, Rainbow Sprinkles
- Average Visit Duration: 15 minutes
On the menu
Top picks at Schoolhouse Creamery
Signature dishes, shareable plates, and the items regulars keep coming back for.
1 
2
3
Amenities & features
What's available at the restaurant
Grouped by category — each group lists what's available and what isn't at Schoolhouse Creamery.
Service options
- Onsite services
- No Delivery
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
Dining options
- No Table service
Amenities
- Wi-Fi
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
Parking
- Paid parking lot
Pets
- Dogs allowed outside
Location
Location & Nearby Places
Central New York, with cafes, shops, and other restaurants within easy walking distance.
Photos
Photos of Schoolhouse Creamery
A look at the food, the dining room, drinks, and the exterior of Schoolhouse Creamery.
Reviews
Reviews for Schoolhouse Creamery
What recent guests say after dining at Schoolhouse Creamery.
4.8/ 5
Based on 273 guest reviews
Soft Ice Cream Sundaes Flavor Selection Hot Fudge Shaded Bench Area Hard Ice Cream Soft Vanilla Seasonal Ice Cream Shop Peanut Butter Sundae Milkshakes
Chelsie Stephenson
May 22, 2026"I loved this place! Small little place right off the highway, easy on, easy off. Very tasty treats!"
BMad the NoMad
May 14, 2026"Easy on and off the highway. Many flavors. Maybe too many. Just kidding. Nice size servings. Efficient service. And did we mention that the ice cream is really good?"
Mehmet Aygun
May 03, 2026"I have seen this creamery just by luck on my way back to home from a long roadtrip. It was just next to my gas exit and wanted to give it a shot. Honestly, I didn’t have high expectations however it was very delicious. It’s recommended."
Maureen Kurkowski
Apr 27, 2026"Charming school house building serving soft serve ice cream (vanilla, chocolate or twist), and myriad of Hershey's ice cream flavors, plus milk shakes, sundaes and banana splits. We enjoyed our treats on the shaded, clean picnic tables. Plenty of napkins in their dispensers. Bring your own wet wipes and water to drink."
Mary Naughton
Apr 20, 2026"This is a nice ice cream shop away from town over in Windsor off Exit 77. They have Hershey’s ice cream and soft serve options. There are many flavors to choose from but be mindful of the size you want. The size in my pictures is small. If you’d want one even smaller, ask for a kid size. I’ll have to do that next time."
Lorna Williams
Apr 14, 2026"GPS directed us off the interstate and we saw the little sign for the creamery. What better stop to make than ice cream? Yummy! And it’s right off the exit."
Tlc Tlc
Mar 30, 2026"Good Stuff! They make ice-cream and they do it right. Soft, creamy, sweet, and full of flavor = great summer treat. When we first drove by it was closed, so I thought we were out of luck, but what really happened is I didn’t know the weekend operating hours. Lol. Midday, just happened to be passing and the line was rather inviting. Had a waffle cone with midnight caramel scoop + a bourbon scoop and both were delicious. Large parking lot, a shaded bench area and an easy spoken lady running the orders. The type of setting where you immediately get the notion, they don’t see too many-colored folk around those parts’ vibe. Cordial greetings amongst patrons were null."
FAQs
Frequently asked questions
Common questions to help plan a visit to Schoolhouse Creamery.
Only onsite service is available; delivery is not offered. Visitors purchase and enjoy ice cream at the location.
Yes, there is a wheelchair accessible entrance to accommodate guests with mobility needs.
Payments can be made using credit cards and debit cards. Cash options are not specified.
Dogs are permitted outside the building, making it pet-friendly for outdoor visitors.
There is no table service, but shaded picnic bench seating is provided for guests to enjoy their ice cream outdoors.
Popular options include chocolate ice cream, vanilla and chocolate twists, and treats topped with rainbow sprinkles. Milkshakes and sundaes are also offered.
A paid parking lot is located nearby, offering convenient access for those arriving by car.
Most visitors spend around 15 minutes, making it a quick stop for a refreshing treat.
Restaurant
Barão do Retiro Bar e Restaurante
R. Barão do Retiro, 777 - Bonfim, Juiz de Fora - MG, 36051-470, Brazil
4.5 View
Pizza Restaurant
Dom Pericles Pizzaria
cpa 3 - Av. 2 - Morada da Serra, Cuiabá - MT, 78056-809, Brazil
4.1 View
Restaurant
Es Kelapa Muda
QHC4+C8X, Jl. Salatiga-Kedungjati, Ngelo, Gogodalem, Kec. Bringin, Kabupaten Semarang, Jawa Tengah 50772, Indonesia
4.6 View
Restaurant
Ken Chicken & BBQ
Jl. Wolter Monginsidi No.180, Kupang Kota, Kec. Tlk. Betung Utara, Kota Bandar Lampung, Lampung 35211, Indonesia
3.6 View
Cafe
Warkop SPS
Cabak, RT.04/RW.02, Kerep, Kec. Tarokan, Kabupaten Kediri, Jawa Timur 64152, Indonesia
4.9 View
For business owners
Own or manage this restaurant?
Keep your listing accurate by updating your address, opening hours, menu, photos, and contact details. Reach more diners searching for Ice Cream Shop in New York on Locallya.
- Free to claim & verify
- Edit menu & hours anytime
- Respond to customer reviews
- Track views & engagement